When you have a kid, you start thinking about stuff that never registered much before. Like the beauty of a simple sunset and pretty horses and, wait, not that stuff. Stuff like, hmm, when I open my wallet, flies fly out. I wonder if I could lower my weekly French toast bill without compromising on quality?
I used to buy challah for French toast at Noah’s Bagels. It was good bread and made great toast. I think it was about $3.50, and it was baked fresh every Friday. Then one day they changed their formula and gave me a sad, flattened loaf. It was an April 1, I remember, because I wondered whether I was the victim of a many-braided bread hoax, another indignity visited on my people.
So I went to QFC and found they were selling much larger and less misshapen store-brand loaves of challah. The QFC bread was baked in a loaf pan, dyed yellow with annatto coloring, and not much fun to eat by itself, but by the time it in French toast batter, it was basically indistinguishable from the old Noah’s formula.
Then, a couple of months ago, the QFC brand disappeared, replaced with some natural-sounding local brand. It was good, just as good as Old Noah, but the loaves are tiny, not even enough for two weeks of toast. And the price is an outrageous $4.50.
It was time to try abandoning challah altogether and going right back to Texas. I bought a loaf of Franz Texas Toast, the thick-sliced white sandwich bread, and used my regular, Cooks Illustrated-derived batter.
As you’ve already guessed, this toast was just as good as any of the others, and the price is unbeatable. A loaf of Texas Toast is $2, and it has enough slices for three breakfasts. (Sliced bread is fine in the freezer, in a Ziploc, for several weeks.)
Here’s the recipe. Unless you’re partial to highly enriched bread for your French toast, like brioche or croissant, I’m willing to bet this is better than what you make now. All thanks to Christopher Kimball and the state of Texas.
**French Toast**
Serves 2 adults and 1 child
Adapted from The New Best Recipe
5 slices Texas Toast or other thick-sliced white sandwich bread
1 egg
2 tablespoons (1 ounce) butter, melted
3/4 cup (6 ounces) milk
2 teaspoons vanilla
1/3 cup (1.6 ounces) flour
2 tablespoons sugar
1/4 teaspoon table salt
additional butter
1. Crack the egg into a pie plate. Whisk in the butter, then the milk and vanilla, then the sugar, flour, and salt.
2. Place a ten- or twelve-inch skillet (not nonstick) over medium heat. Soak the bread slices in the batter for 40 seconds per side, and set them aside on a plate as you finish.
3. Melt 1/2 tablespoon butter in the pan. Cook the bread slices, two at a time, until nicely browned on both sides, adjusting the heat if necessary. I find it takes about 2-1/2 minutes for the first side and 1-1/2 for the second side, but subsequent batches go faster.
4. Enjoy, with fake syrup.